Independent senator Derryn Hinch said he hoped part of the company tax bill could still be saved.
"If they put it at $500 million I would vote for it tomorrow," he said ahead of a meeting with the Coalition's chief negotiator Mathias Cormann next week.
There is no contingency plan to restrict the cut to $500 million, "at this stage", a government source said.
Economists have lashed the proposal from the crossbenchers, warning it will encourage businesses to stop growing and keep their turnover below $500 million a year.
"The dividing line is entirely because of politics not economics," said Deloitte Access Economics partner Chris Richardson.
Grattan Institute chief executive John Daley said restricting the cuts was "nothing like a first best solution," and that the economic benefit of the changes was derived from corporations who employ the most people.
"It really does create incentives for companies to stay under a certain size," said Mr Daley.
Unlike personal income taxes, which are divided by brackets, company taxes are paid on every dollar of profit.
"If all of a sudden a company tips over the threshold, the company starts paying more tax across all of its profits," said Mr Daley.
One Nation has indicated further negotiations with the government are off the table but the party has changed its stance on tax several times in the past two years.
A spokesman denied its backflip was due to the upcoming Longman byelection in Queensland, where recent ReachTEL polling by the Australia Institute found up to 38 per cent of One Nation voters wanted company taxes increased.
"We haven't seen any polling, it has nothing to do with Longman," he said. "It was the budget papers, they spoke loud and clear."
Senator Hinch confirmed One Nation had been lobbying him "passionately and at great length" to support the company tax cuts days after the budget, where One Nation was disappointed not to see a commitment to an apprenticeship scheme and increases in taxes paid on resources.
The executive director of the left-leaning institute, Ben Oquist, said the think tank had launched a campaign targeting One Nation voters and senators to help kill off the tax cuts ahead of the Longman poll.
"Labor’s citizenship byelections have cruelled Turnbull's tax cuts," said the institute's chief economist Richard Denniss.
Eryk Bagshaw is an economics reporter for the Sydney Morning Herald and The Age, based in Parliament House
Morning & Afternoon Newsletter
Delivered Mon–Fri.