Add Category
Naturally, we have a non-smoking policy at work. The majority of our team in our office do not smoke. However, we have a new team member, a very capable individual, who smokes heavily.
When this person returns to the office from their frequent smoke breaks we have to suffer their nauseous toxic nicotine smell which permeates the office and has forced some of us to walk out or stay and gag or feel like throwing up. I have advised HR. Advice?
Just because someone is excellent at their job doesn’t mean they’re a good fit for the company. Credit: John Shakespeare
I asked Dr Xiaoshuang Lin, a senior lecturer in the University of South Australia’s Centre for Workplace Excellence, about your question, and she told me that advising HR was the right course of action. Discussing it with the smoker in person probably isn’t the best way to go, at least not at the moment.
Now that you’ve let HR know, it’s really up to them to solve this problem. They might respond in different ways, and to understand what they could be, a little primer on human resources theory might be useful.
“In human resource management, we focus on different types of ‘fit’ between employees and their work environment, such as person-job fit, person-team fit, person-supervisor fit and person-organisation fit,” Lin explained.
Your new colleague, someone who is good at their job, is an example of a strong person-job fit.
“However, when we consider the person-team fit, things are different. Other team members working in the same office suffer from the unpleasant and harmful smell, which leads to a poor person-team fit. Additionally, the organisation has a non-smoking policy, meaning this employee also has a poor person-organisation fit.”
Now that you’ve let HR know how badly the stench affects you and others, you can expect quite different approaches depending on what your organisation values most. And you might get a sense of what that is by having a look at a strategy document or, Lin suggested, simply considering the company’s culture.
“If the company has a culture that prioritises employee wellbeing, often referred to as a people-oriented culture, the smoking employee should not negatively impact their colleagues.